Debunking Immigration Myths: ‘Public Charge’ | NBC News Now

Debunking Immigration Myths: ‘Public Charge’ | NBC News Now


PUBLIC ASSISTANCE. SO REACH INTO THE COUNTRY’S SO REACH INTO THE COUNTRY’S IMMIGRATION LAWS TO FIND OUT HOW IMMIGRATION LAWS TO FIND OUT HOW MUCH OF AN IMPACT THIS MAY HAVE. MUCH OF AN IMPACT THIS MAY HAVE.>>>>>>>>>>WE WERE GOING TO GO ON THE>>WE WERE GOING TO GO ON THE WELFARE SYSTEM. WELFARE SYSTEM. THE PRESIDENT TALKED ABOUT THIS THE PRESIDENT TALKED ABOUT THIS OVER AND OVER. OVER AND OVER. HE SAID, I’M SIMPLY TIRED OF HE SAID, I’M SIMPLY TIRED OF IMMIGRANTS THAT COME HERE AND IMMIGRANTS THAT COME HERE AND IMMEDIATELY GO ON WELFARE. IMMEDIATELY GO ON WELFARE. AND BENDING THE RULE, THE AND BENDING THE RULE, THE CITIZENSHIP DIRECTOR SAID THIS CITIZENSHIP DIRECTOR SAID THIS IS ABOUT 140 YEARS OF IS ABOUT 140 YEARS OF EXPECTATIONS, THAT PEOPLE WHO EXPECTATIONS, THAT PEOPLE WHO EMIGRATE TO THIS COUNTRY SHOULD EMIGRATE TO THIS COUNTRY SHOULD NOT BE PART OF OUR SYSTEM. NOT BE PART OF OUR SYSTEM. WAY BACK IN 1882, CONGRESS WAY BACK IN 1882, CONGRESS PASSED THE FIRST EVER PASSED THE FIRST EVER IMMIGRATION PLAUM, GETTING IMMIGRATION PLAUM, GETTING PEOPLE TO PAY THEIR CARDS. PEOPLE TO PAY THEIR CARDS. BUT HERE’S THE THING, EYE BUT HERE’S THE THING, EYE DECLARATION OF A PUBLIC CHARGE DECLARATION OF A PUBLIC CHARGE HAS CHAUNGD A AN WELFARE STATE HAS CHAUNGD A AN WELFARE STATE THAT WE HAVE. THAT WE HAVE. THERE IS NO SOCIAL SECURITY, NO THERE IS NO SOCIAL SECURITY, NO FOOD STAMPS. FOOD STAMPS. THOSE PROGRAMS DIDN’T START THOSE PROGRAMS DIDN’T START UNTIL THE 1930s WHCHLT DO YOU UNTIL THE 1930s WHCHLT DO YOU WORK FOR MEDICARE TO DO BE ABLE WORK FOR MEDICARE TO DO BE ABLE TO ADD TO MEDICAID. TO ADD TO MEDICAID. I KNOW ONCE IN A WHILE, A DON’T I KNOW ONCE IN A WHILE, A DON’T HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY FOR A DACA HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY FOR A DACA RECIPIENT. RECIPIENT. THEY COME HERE. THEY COME HERE. THEY WORK. THEY WORK. THEY PAY BILLIONS INTO OUR THEY PAY BILLIONS INTO OUR SYSTEM AND THEY’RE NOT IN A SYSTEM AND THEY’RE NOT IN A POSITION TO EVEN APPLY. POSITION TO EVEN APPLY. SO WHEN THE PRESIDENT SAYS, I SO WHEN THE PRESIDENT SAYS, I DON’T WANT TO SEE THESE DON’T WANT TO SEE THESE IMMIGRANTS GETTING WELFARE, HE IMMIGRANTS GETTING WELFARE, HE DOESN’T HAVE THE CURRENT RULE.

Author:

30 thoughts on “Debunking Immigration Myths: ‘Public Charge’ | NBC News Now”

  • https://www.forbes.com/sites/niallmccarthy/2016/10/06/how-much-tax-do-americas-undocumented-immigrants-actually-pay-infographic/#1312b9e91de0 

    Many who do not file tax returns still have taxes deducted from their pay checks. Out of that $11.64 billion total, undocumented immigrants pay $6.9 billion in sales and excise taxes, $3.6 billion in property taxes and about $1.1 billion in personal income taxes. ITEP estimated that if America's 11 million undocumented immigrants were granted citizenship allowing them to work legally, current state and tax contributions would be boosted by over $2.1 billion a year.

  • Why don't we just tax these workers? There is a need for these people in fields that Americans don't want to do. Especially in the hot humid or super hot Southern States. People who move from the north can not handle these jobs.

  • ipressedabutton says:

    i really DON'T respect NBC, but i can't watch fox news, they are too butt-kissy to mr trump for my taste. NBC will just come right out and hit him hard.. which is OK by me ..

  • ipressedabutton says:

    its unreasonable to ask that all immigrants not be a public charge. life is often less than ideal. when people get here, they have no connections, they have no land on which to begin their work efforts, they own nothing, and the government needs to pick up the tab for them. no man on planet earth deserves to own NO LAND .. not even a 2 foot x 2 foot square beneath their own feet. something is wrong here, the government isn't cutting the pie evenly.. i don't need a degree in mathematics to establish that truth.

  • Finally someone who says it but americans are to stupid t pay attention they just want to absorb the information that pleases themm. Brainwashed by headass Trump.

  • That's what we did with New Zealanders coming here in Australia. They migrate here and go on welfare right away and never gets off, so Gov't made stipulation they don't get benefits nor permanaent residence if they don't earn 56k for 3 consecutive years and we deport all Kiwis who have convictions right after they serve their sentences.
    Their PM Ardern doesn't like it. Lol

  • That's not true. Illegal immigrants dont pay taxes. Their employer pays less wages and flys under the tax radar. Then the illegal immigrant sends the tax free money back home, outside the U.S. So, which is to blame? Is this the essence of the problem? Greed?
    The problem is a few fold.

    Point is, they don't pay taxes because they do not hold a SSN. Therefore, they don't pay for the infrastructure, unemployment, food stamps, social security.. etc.
    Now, there are those that assume, illegally, the SSN of a deceased individual and use it, exclusively, for collecting benefits.

    Some of my best childhood and current friends are here illegally. Always have been. This is how I know.

    IMO, it's the illgal' employer's that have caused this twisted blame. The illegals have no other avenues once their work visas expire. However, just as if I were to want to expatriate myself into another country I would have to follow their laws and rules not just out of legitimacy but out of respect. In other words once anyones work visa expires its time to file for citizenship legally just like I would have to do in , say Japan. Let me tell you. … I cherish my Mexican friendships. Beautiful people. I won't compare them to anyone.. on their own merits. God bless every nation. Peace brothers.

  • No your talking about Illegal Aliens and Anchor Babies, let's be clear on that. And if you think Illegals are not gaming the system and getting it, then your as dumb as this Woman. Of course this Video is made by a Liberal Dem news outlet posing as a legitimate news source and not admitting their Political agenda to you. Very dishonest.

  • He had no problem, with allowing Amazon to go on the Corporate welfare role. They made 10 billion dollars and paid no taxes. I can understand illegal immigrants not getting welfare benefits. But I allow healthcare. I wouldn't deny my worst enemy medical help if they needed it. Anyone that does has a moral deficit.

  • An Outstanding report so far. I have see so many reports and news over Public Charge. This could persuade the jury to prevent the rule from taking place.

  • The law would be about maintenance healthcare. Emergency healthcare is still covered. Lets keep that in mind as this is discussed. Every country has a "Hippocratic" Oath of some some kind. The average people's of the world are good.

  • Never too flashy, nor ever without compassion; that's why Ms. Ruhle has become one of my favorite journalists! Thank-you, Stephanie, for pointing out this particular absurdity of Trump policy with your usual common sense eloquence. You rule!

  • If President Trump and other businessmen didn't hire them to work in his hotels and their be there construction they wouldn't come over here they come over here for work and McDonald's and all you guys are the ones who are giving them to work they don't take the work from Americans mr. Trump and the people who hire them take the work from America's and they're the ones that bring them over here this problem can be so easily fixed but you guys just won't do it

  • That's not new.
    It's in the immigration book. Plain as day!
    It is a very good policy and is fairly common in other countries (Australia used to have one, probably still does)
    The socialist European countries all wish they had this as immigration policy, that's for sure.

  • GaysAgainstAbortion says:

    Jeez woman, can u get off the President a bit?! he is, like, the first one we've had in a very long time that cannot be bought.

  • The Statue of liberty nor that poem or poet are rules or laws in the USA. The Statue was given to us by the french however the french do not rule us either and false they get welfare through their anchor babies food stamps etc

  • The premise is the same. Who cares what old laws regulated. ASK 1000 people what your country needs? 1 moron will say that we need more immigrants on welfare.

  • Raymond Kidwell says:

    1886-1959: we don't need idiots. We celebrate our abilities and accomplishments and are a white nation, Christian culture with Western values.

    Starting in 1960: We celebrate disabilities. Our society is measured by how it treats the lowest people. We demonize the smart and successful. We demonize white people and sing "hey hey ho ho Western culture has got to go" We smear feces on portraits of Jesus. And then we wonder why our schools are failing, bridges collapsing, mass shootings all over the place, widespread poverty etc. I have news for NBC: the two are are connected. So yes bring in your 8th grade drop outs if you like, but don't go complaining about massive poverty and crime or the widespread incarceration that follows it.

  • Philosophical-Zombie says:

    all Humans
    detain all hispanics
    99% of them are not Human
    they are Human eating malevolent alien hybrids
    they are trying to blend in amongst you with goals to breed you out and contaminate your DNA so u cannot ascend 
    DETAIN THEM ALL

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *